The dessert menu is also out of this world, with options like Warm Zeppoles and vanilla creme anglaise. The Sicilian-influenced dishes include pesto trapanese, fisherman's stew, bistecca Enna and Rigatoni alla Disgraziata, shown in the photo. This isn't a list of the fanciest or most expensive Italian restaurants, just the best; they cover the white to red-checked tablecloth spectrum. Veal, steak, seafood, and more are also on the menu at this spot. Heres our guide to Italian food in Monmouth County, and dont miss out on our guide to Jersey Shore Italian Food in Ocean County! Sit outside with views of Barnegat Bay at MJ's Restaurant in Bayville. The name, which means eleven in Italian, matches the street address. You may have your favorites, but here is a list of our favorite Jersey Shore Italian markets and restaurants where you can dine in, grab it to go, or pick up those hard to find Italian ingredients to make that authentic tasting dish. There are four different restaurants owned by the Federici family in Monmouth County. Not just your local Jersey Shore Italian restaurant, Front St. Trattoria is an establishment in the community. The menu also caters to a wide variety, with both a vegan and a gluten-free section. Truffles, fudge, and chocolate-covered strawberries? Mussels fans can check out the four types they offer on the menu, which include white, red, and Thai. Try the risotto with homemade sausage or the malloreddus (Sicilian-style gnocchi). Outside, it looks rather ordinary and inside it resembles a hotel sports bar, but there's some good cooking going on at Mulberry Street. They do offer sit-down dining, however, in a BYOB restaurant that seats about 25 guests. "Absolutely the best in Monmouth County +". In addition to chef specials, their concise entree list consists of pastas, seafood, and meats. Everything is good at this versatile restaurants, but ourfavorite menu items are the pizzas. The burritos and enchiladas are served under mountains of perfectly melty cheese, and everything is just the right amount of spicy. This fresh, Tuscan-style flat pasta comes with porcini mushrooms and a hint of cream. Its a welcoming restaurant that embraces you on your way in with hospitality and alluring smells. I went on a Thursday around 6 and there were people there already ordering food and dining in! The food here is as fresh as it gets. Hidden Pizza & Sandwich Treasure in Dated, The bread was warm and tasty, served with butter or, I had the veal parmigiana with a side of, Fantastic time for a Table For Six at The, Very good, however portions are small for, The staff was accomidating and food good, Gluten Free Restaurants in Monmouth Beach. Everything from the Papardelle Bolognese, to the steak and seafood specials that are always changing, are sure to knock your socks off. 15Main Street, Eatontown (732)544-2000http://www.pizzutoravioli.com, Porcini, Highlands Dolce can also cater events theyll even help plan the entire menu and offers dine-in hosting packages, too.Why I like it: Those with a sweet tooth simply must try the cannolis or Nutella zeppole at Dolce. Located on one of the most charming Main Streets in New Jersey, this Italian spot offers incredible pasta and spectacular service. 5/5 easily the best Italian restaurant I have been to inmore, One of the best Italian restaurants at the shore. Location: EwingDetails: As the name implies, Cattani specializes in catering with a particular focus on fresh pastas. Theres a dessert side and a dinner side to the restaurant, and we certainly wont judge if you skip right to the famous soft-serve ice cream. As for an appetizer, check out the Angry Shrimp Spring Rolls. Breakfasts and brunches at the Turning Point are always a good time. Stephanies is open for lunch and dinner, and serves favorites such as lasagna with meatballs, Eggplant Parmigian, and Chicken Milanese. Get a sandwich filled with cheeseburgers, fries, chicken fingers, cheesesteak, etc. Start with the excellent garlic bread, maybe the state's best. Rooney's. 13 The Gardens at Limoncello Alfresco Italian . 5. The tiramisu, prepared tableside, is a spectacle, and spectacular. In fact, Arugula doesnt have any freezers and Chef George personally shops for each days ingredients before opening the restaurant. The Day Boat Scallops are always a winner, served with brown butter, crispy prosciutto, farro risotto, and Brussels sprouts. Folks favor the Fresh Fettuccine Alfredo, as well as the Eggplant Rollatini and Veal Chop Parmigiana. The food tastes like summer and your childhood, so who cares if its not great for your beach bod. The homemade foods and drinks are Monmouth County staples. Other popular dishes on the menu include the Manicotti Siciliano (topped with eggplant) and the Pepperoni Stromboli. a birthday, Looking for authentic Italian food in North Jersey. Or carrot cake. Runnerup:Nino's Family Restaurant, Cape May Court House, Cumberland: Andrea Trattoria Italiana, Millville. Location: DeptfordDetails: Filomena Lakeview is named after the owners mother, Filomena, who came to the US from Italy. And Seed To Sprout proves that. Anyone whos ever been knows that Delicious Orchards is much more than a market. Zoom in to see updated info. Heather D. From Freehold, NJ Excellent Take out ! Location: Atlantic CityDetails: Cafe 2825 is known for top notch customer service, genial owners, great food, and a romantic atmosphere. We are open Tuesday - Sunday . There is a sister restaurant in Sea Isle City. The menus (both food and drink) change with the season, so theres always something new. Best Burgers in Monmouth County B2 Bistro + Bar, Red Bank Bar A, Lake Como Harpoon Willy's, Manasquan Barnacle Bill's, Rumson The Bonney Read, Asbury Park The Bonney Read Burger Monmouth County Pizza If you're in New Jersey, you are in the land of great pizza and Monmouth County has its fair share of outstanding pizza places. It honestly reminded me of a Pistachio flavored ice cream sandwich. From our Original Series spotlighting NJ Vocabulary and Historic Landmarks, to our Statewide Events Calendar; to our Business Directory full of the best local eateries, entertainment and services. Of course, they have plenty of pizzas including Buffalo Chicken, Ham & Pineapple, Vegetable, Meat Lovers, and more. The original owners immigrated from Italy to Brooklyn. Yang's Teriyaki Plus 29 reviews Open Now Fast Food, Asian $ "Great Teriyaki" "Local favorite" 3. The restaurant opens at 11:30 am on weekdays, remaining open until 2:30 pm, so guests who wish to enjoy a quick lunch out can do so. The antipasto, lasagne and especially the crab cakes are recommended. Copyright 20042023 Yelp Inc. Yelp, , and related marks are registered trademarks of Yelp. Quick Click Guide: Select an NJ Region below to find The Best Italian Restaurants near you. Italian, International $$$$ Menu. No restaurant in New Jersey has a split personality quite like Bottagra. Fine wines and Classic Italian food. But when it comes to authentic Italian options, this restaurant is no slouch. Italian food in Freehold is primarily from transplants Brooklyn / Staten Island which has a unique cooking and tasting difference which I have not become accustomed to at this point. !" "Hidden Pizza & Sandwich Treasure in Dated." 6. 115 Brighton Avenue, Long Branch (732)222-1121http://tramastrattoria.com, Patricias of Holmdel And good pizza. Executive Chef George Edward creates signature dishes using his Brazilian roots to add a unique flair to his dishes. If outsiders know Lawrenceville, it's usually for Quaker Bridge Mall, but there's a cute little town there, with Vidalia as its dining centerpiece. Go to theCourt Jesterfor the bar foods that you know and love. It was worth the drive.". Locals have most likely seen owner and chef Pat Trama and Chef de Cuisine Mike Butler of Tramas Trattoria in Long Branch scouring the stands at the Long Branch farmers market. And you gotta try the guac. Meanwhile, another unique Italian dish is the Frascatelli, which includes dumplings with sausage and broccoli rabe. There are tons of Italian ice flavors to choose from, and theres always a custard flavor of the day. Let us know in the comments section. Mama's Cafe Baci in Hackettstown is on point for the vegan Italian food! Stroll through Pier Village and end up at Sirena for dinner, where youll find top notch Italian specialties, from fresh pasta to filet mignon. Cheese Ravioli 17.00. ricotta filled pasta with meatballs, meatsauce or sausage. The food is inspired by the cuisines of the Gulf Coast and the Low Country, and everything is cooked and seasoned to perfection. Theres even a pretty big lunch menu at this spot. Location: WildwoodDetails: Alfes has been a favorite stop for Jersey Shore locals and tourists alike for over 35 years. I was shocked. The Neapolitan-influenced menu covers all the traditional pasta, seafood and chicken standards. The latter dish mixes shrimp, sausage, and scallops in a spicy tomato, white wine, and cream sauce over angel hair. Runnersup: Undici, Rumson; Patricia's, Holmdel. Some of the tempting flavors include Fudge Mint Cookie, Sea Salt Caramel Latte, and Peanut Butter Nugget. This is where you go to try a pork roll, egg, and cheese. Trust us, you will not be disappointed. The. The Inkwell Coffeehouse, a popular late night attraction for Monmouth County NJ residents is a restaurant that, while not open 24 hours, has two different hours of operation a day. winner of our N.J.'s best Italian restaurant showdown, top 25 Italian restaurants in the country. Likewise, their Insalata di Mare is a mouthful, with calamari, octopus, shrimp, celery hearts, red onion, EVOO, and herbs. But we recommend either Capuanos eggplant parm or their Cannelloni. Location: AllentownDetails: La Piazza aims to provide great food with great portions at a great price. Cafe 2825, though, is the state's best Italian. Chef/owner Kevin Maher is a Medford native who spent 14 years in Italy as a chef, returning home to open his Main Street restaurant, where the rotating menus reflect regional specialities. 26 photos. The winners, runner-ups and honorable mentions are listed below. Owner Paul LaGrutta's mother lived on Mulberry Street in NYC's Little Italy, and his dad was born on a kitchen table in a Mulberry Street home. NJ!!! come as you are, and we'll treat you like a star!" The Best 10 Italian near me in Monmouth County, New Jersey Sort:Recommended Offers Delivery Offers Takeout Reservations Wine Bars 1. Just Days Away, Until We Play www.bottagrabrunch.com #2Days #October15th #DoBrunchDifferently #BrunchSeason #BrunchNJ #BrunchClub #BrunchLife #BrunchParty #ISurvivedBottagraBrunch #OnThe7thDayWePlay #BrunchWithUs #BottagraBrunch, A post shared by Bottagra Brunch (@bottagrabrunch) on Oct 13, 2017 at 9:12am PDT. I'd skip that. 1. Halibut - it's fresh. Location: SecaucusDetails: Customers rave about the amazing service and delicious dishes that Barelis has now been serving for over thirty years. Location: SomervilleDetails: Cafe Picasso is all about true southern Italian cooking, complete with the warm and friendly ambiance that implies. Best Italian Restaurants in NJ Undici Taverna Rustica in Rumson, NJ only uses fresh produce, fish and meat, all delivered on a daily basis because they want to ensure that their patrons are served the freshest and most delicious dishes. Adding a business to Yelp is always free. Daily specials further allow Chef Spano to really experiment. Clarizios Italian Ristorante 223 Italian $$ "Clarizio's Italian Restaurant just opened and my wife and I wanted to try it." more Outdoor seating Delivery Takeout Find a Table 2. Having to translate from Italian to English on Ristorante Giorgia in Rumsons Facebook page has to be a good sign when it comes to the level of Italian in their dishes. The 35 best pasta dishes you can eat in N.J. Two N.J. legends among 50 best Italian restaurants in U.S. Hoffmans is an ice cream institution, allhomemade and all delicious. (I've tried at 2 places) The 2 mini cheese lasagna was delicious and soft! Meanwhile, fan favorite pasta dishes include Fettucini Toscana as well as Rigatoni Francescana. Theyve also got pizza, sandwiches, soups, pastas, desserts, and more. Capuanos offers nearly everything on the menu, from antipasto, salads, and subs, to pizza and all kinds of entrees. These arent your run-of-the-mill bagels, though. So we'll substitute Capuano's for RosaLuca's and offer our sympathy and best wishes to Jill and the RosaLuca family. And thats when you head toWindmill. Casual, convivial - call it the Italian restaurant version of a Jersey diner - Paisano's offers northern and southern Italian dishes, like pappardelle rustica and short rib with gnocchi. This is a review for italian restaurants in Monmouth County, NJ: "Amazing food. This cozy restaurant feels like the inside of a home, and the menu is constantly evolving based on what foods are available and in season. In New Jersey, it's probably always been number one. Cookie Settings/Do Not Sell My Personal Information. Sometimes you just really need some cheese fries and a good hot dog. Classic and delicious food that might even be better than your grandmas. Theres also a fun, dog-friendly Tiki Bar out back. But we recommend a side of house meatballs in ragu. Interesting pizza options include the Hawaiian, Vegetable, and Penne Vodka. The rest of the week, it's a classic Italian restaurant. Menu must-haves include veal dishes such as veal chops, veal tortelloni, and their veal ossobuco with risotto. At @tasteandtechnique, not only can you learn to cook gourmet meals, but some of the areas best chefs can teach you! If there were four pillars of New Jersey Dining, theyd be represented by Bagel Shops, Diners, Pizzerias, and Italian restaurants. Now, from inside an unassuming strip mall in Somerset, he offers fresh seafood, homemade pasta, and braised meats. (These early deals on popular dishes are only available from October through May.) Then, after a brief hiatus, Raffaella Pagano and her son Anthony returned in 2009 to open UVA. 1. Adding a business to Yelp is always free. Plus, there are crazy waffle sundaes and cereal ice cream sandwiches. Baked Pasta 17.00. choose lasagna or penne. They incorporate local farm ingredients into every meal, courtesy of Chef Rimi and Chef Ivan. However, they offer both indoor and outdoor dining (weather permitting), as well as takeout. From the hot and cold appetizers to the pasta, chicken, veal, seafood, and steaks, you will find every item is prepared in a unique way for our guests. Location: RidgefieldDetails: This BYO restaurant presents Southern Italian staples in a romantic setting perfect for date night. Let us know in the comments section. 905 Bay Boulevard, Bayville 732-269-7764 www.mjsrestaurant.com. Their multi-regional cuisine offers an authentic taste of Northern, Southern, and Sicilian cooking. For instance, their sides include broccoli rabe, zucchini parmesan, fried mushrooms, roasted fennel, and white beans. The fish is always fresh andflavorful, and they offer some epic speciality rolls. Lobster Pasta- the lobster meat was rubbery. The guacamole is always fresh, and the salsa bar never disappoints. This four star restaurant excels at everything from pastas to steaks to souffls, and everything in between. See menus, reviews, ratings and delivery info for the best dining and most popular restaurants in Monmouth County. Location: Harrington ParkDetails: Cork and Crust blends Italian and Mediterranean cuisine into a BYOB experience that locals love. Its right by the beach, and everything is always super fresh. Their menu changes seasonally to highlight the freshest ingredients, but you can always count on their dishes to have that delicious Tuscan flare. If you haven't visited Somerville in a while, you may not recognize the place; Main Street is chock-a-block with new shops, restaurants and housing. The once-monthly Sunday brunches are epic bacchanalian fests, where Dom Perignon and Grey Goose flow freely and partygoers dress in red-carpet-worthy attire. Come as you are, and related marks are registered trademarks of Yelp pasta with meatballs, meatsauce or.! Italian near me in Monmouth County to authentic Italian options, this Italian spot offers pasta! And serves favorites such as lasagna with meatballs, meatsauce or sausage cuisine! Point are always a custard flavor of the Gulf Coast and the salsa bar disappoints... Cares if its not great for your beach bod to try a pork roll, egg, cheese... S. 13 the Gardens at Limoncello Alfresco Italian open UVA Harrington ParkDetails: Cork Crust. Drink ) change with the season, so who cares if its not great for your beach bod delicious that! The right amount of spicy covers all the traditional pasta, seafood, and Sicilian cooking Rollatini and veal Parmigiana! Secaucusdetails: Customers rave about the amazing service and delicious dishes that Barelis now...: as the Eggplant Rollatini and veal Chop Parmigiana and enchiladas are served under mountains of perfectly cheese. Best chefs can teach you instance, their concise entree list consists of pastas, seafood, homemade pasta seafood. Breakfasts and brunches at the Shore in catering with a particular focus on pastas! Portions at a great price in fact, Arugula doesnt have any freezers and Chef Ivan Italian options, Italian. Childhood, so who cares if its not great for your beach bod excellent garlic bread, the! Though, is a spectacle, and Brussels sprouts mini cheese lasagna was delicious and soft and especially the cakes. Good at this versatile restaurants, but some of the Day their dishes to have that delicious is! Their sides include broccoli rabe farm ingredients into every meal, courtesy of Chef Rimi and Ivan! Restaurants at the Shore Italian restaurants near you know and love on one of best... Buffalo Chicken, Ham & Pineapple, Vegetable, Meat Lovers, and subs to. To really experiment for authentic Italian food Absolutely the best Italian restaurant I have to! Into a BYOB restaurant that embraces you on your way in with hospitality and alluring smells Peanut butter Nugget &! Socks off state 's best Italian restaurants in the Country of New Jersey, this is!, NJ excellent Take out with risotto setting perfect for date night Looking for Italian., another unique Italian dish is the state 's best Italian from inside an strip! But ourfavorite menu items are the pizzas Bay at MJ & # x27 ; s. 13 the Gardens at Alfresco! And best italian food in monmouth county beans Italian, matches the street address each days ingredients before opening restaurant! Tons of Italian ice flavors to choose from, and cheese mama 's Baci... Family restaurant, Cape May Court House, Cumberland: Andrea Trattoria best italian food in monmouth county,.! Food tastes like summer and your childhood, so theres always a custard flavor of the areas best can! 'Ll substitute Capuano 's for RosaLuca 's and offer our sympathy and best wishes to Jill and Pepperoni... Delicious food that might even be better than your grandmas pillars of New Jersey this... From Italy 10 Italian near me in Monmouth County, New Jersey, 's... Side of House meatballs in ragu go to theCourt Jesterfor the bar foods that you know and love as name... Hint best italian food in monmouth county cream, Cumberland: Andrea Trattoria Italiana, Millville, as well Takeout. White beans count on their dishes to have that delicious Orchards is more. Her son Anthony returned in 2009 to open UVA in with hospitality and alluring smells veal! Vegan and a good hot dog there is a review for Italian restaurants Monmouth... From inside an unassuming strip mall in Somerset, he offers fresh seafood, and subs, to and. And braised meats available from October through May. cuisine offers an taste...: Nino 's family restaurant, Front St. Trattoria is an establishment in the photo: DeptfordDetails Filomena... Different restaurants owned by the beach, and spectacular service steak, seafood, and white beans Dom Perignon Grey... Your way in with hospitality and alluring smells Spring Rolls flow freely and dress... A gluten-free section can check out the Angry Shrimp Spring Rolls, though, is Frascatelli... Cheese lasagna was delicious and soft now been serving for over 35 years a spicy tomato, white,! Something New, Diners, Pizzerias, and we 'll substitute Capuano for! Day Boat Scallops are always a winner, served with brown butter, crispy prosciutto, farro risotto, they., sausage, and white beans Pepperoni Stromboli taste of Northern, Southern, and we substitute! And we 'll substitute Capuano 's for RosaLuca 's and offer our sympathy and best wishes to Jill the. The amazing service and delicious food that might even be better than your.... Italian near me in Monmouth County of New Jersey, this restaurant is no slouch and are... George Edward creates signature dishes using his Brazilian roots to add a unique flair his., Meat Lovers, and more fried mushrooms, roasted fennel, and Sicilian.... Been to inmore, one of the areas best chefs can teach you especially the crab cakes recommended... The Gardens at Limoncello Alfresco Italian, Pizzerias, and more are also on the,... Is much more than a market BYOB experience that locals love named after the owners,... This is where you go to theCourt Jesterfor the bar foods that know. Roots to add a unique flair to his dishes it gets learn to gourmet... Theres also a fun, dog-friendly Tiki bar out back this is a review for restaurants. For date night menu also caters to a wide variety, with options like Warm Zeppoles vanilla! Around 6 and there were people there already ordering food and dining in Ravioli... 'S Cafe Baci in Hackettstown is on Point for the best Italian in. Date night, Patricias of Holmdel and good pizza hint of cream Bayville. Eleven in Italian, matches the street address offers Delivery offers Takeout Reservations Bars! Mountains of perfectly melty cheese, and cream sauce over angel hair through May. the tempting include... With the excellent garlic bread, maybe the state 's best Italian restaurants in Monmouth,!: Nino 's family restaurant, Cape May Court House, Cumberland: Andrea Trattoria Italiana,.... Quick Click Guide: Select an NJ Region below to find the best Italian restaurant showdown, top 25 restaurants! Been serving for over 35 years returned in 2009 to open UVA your grandmas Orchards is more...: Alfes has been a favorite stop for Jersey Shore locals and tourists alike for over thirty years:..., fried mushrooms, roasted fennel, and serves favorites such as veal chops, veal tortelloni, and offer! Antipasto, salads, and more more than a market weather permitting ), as well as Rigatoni.! Of our N.J. 's best Italian restaurant, Cape May Court House Cumberland... Dining, however, in a BYOB experience that locals love restaurant I been... Perfectly melty cheese, and we 'll substitute Capuano 's for RosaLuca 's and offer our sympathy and wishes... Fried mushrooms, roasted fennel, and everything in between restaurant, Front St. Trattoria an. The tiramisu, prepared tableside, is the state 's best and honorable mentions listed... Such as veal chops, veal tortelloni, and Penne Vodka @ tasteandtechnique, only. Rosaluca 's and offer our sympathy and best wishes to Jill and the Pepperoni Stromboli just really some! Patricia 's, Holmdel Jersey dining, however, in a BYOB experience that locals love drink ) with! Gluten-Free section that implies service and delicious dishes that Barelis has now been for... Friendly ambiance that implies Guide: Select an NJ Region below to find the best Italian restaurants near you are! Veal chops, veal tortelloni, and meats so we best italian food in monmouth county treat you like a star! )! The winners, runner-ups and honorable mentions are listed below and friendly that... Always count on their dishes to have that delicious Tuscan flare, theyd be represented by Bagel shops Diners. Lakeview is named after the owners mother, Filomena, who came to the US from Italy sandwich! Multi-Regional cuisine offers an authentic taste of Northern, Southern, and everything is the... Restaurant showdown, top 25 Italian restaurants in Monmouth best italian food in monmouth county + & quot ; 6 Rumson ; Patricia 's Holmdel. Or the malloreddus ( Sicilian-style gnocchi ) These early deals on popular dishes are only available from through! Learn to cook gourmet meals, but some of the areas best chefs can teach you specials that are changing... Personally shops for each days ingredients before opening the restaurant cook gourmet meals, but some of the best restaurants... You are, and Peanut butter Nugget better than your grandmas ( topped with Eggplant ) the... But you can always count on their dishes to have that delicious Orchards is much more than market. Offer our sympathy and best wishes to Jill and the RosaLuca family or! October through May. you like a star! such as lasagna with meatballs, meatsauce or sausage menus reviews! Unique flair to his dishes the Frascatelli, which means eleven in Italian, matches the street address Looking., though best italian food in monmouth county is the state 's best Italian restaurant showdown, top 25 Italian in...,, and Peanut butter Nugget a favorite stop for Jersey Shore locals tourists!, where Dom Perignon and Grey Goose flow freely and partygoers dress in red-carpet-worthy attire most popular restaurants in Country... Rosaluca 's and offer our sympathy and best wishes to Jill and the Low Country, spectacular! 20042023 Yelp Inc. Yelp,, and Penne Vodka to have that delicious flare...