sds 1911 vs rock island 1911

Jul 14, 2013 There are plenty of threads about Rock Island 1911's, most note that they are great low cost firearms with few quality control issues. The slide-to-frame and barrel fit, while good, is not optimal for the highest level of precision. I spend a lot of time at the range and have seen numerous RIA and SDS/Tisas guns have parts breakages and malfunctions. Most of their GI series, however, is known for mediocre fit and finish, and some suffer from reliability issues that take a gunsmith to fix. Where this pistol is lacking is in the inclusion of many of the upgrades gunsmiths like Bill Wilson made popular. (https://youtu.be/6m41OU54xvk). Youll spend $2500 plus to get there, but buyer beware. The 1911 was introduced, no surprises, in 1911. I trust this gun with my life. Sights Fiber Optic Light Tube Front & Rear-Novak Cut Green/RedRear Sight 1911. I got a 92FS INOX; as Ive gotten more into shooting, Im an old-school weapons kind of gal (10/22, Mini-14 .223/5.56, M1A 6.5 Creedmoor). EFS Stainless Steel 1911 FS8rd 45ACP 8rd . You might save a little money going with the Tisa, but RIA's lifetime warranty is worth the investment and their cs dept is serious about making sure you're happy with your purchase. The extended beavertail is tastefully modern with protection from being bitten by the spur hammer, which even has a subtly reduced profile. Capacity: 7. Accuracy on one was very good, the other moderate. Have a couple RIAs and they are nice for the price. If you want the gun to last you a lifetime I recommend you spend a little more. Rock Island 1911 is very popular, but the availability is a concern. The '06 has been the big-game king forever. Registration on or use of this site constitutes acceptance of our Terms of Service. The first 1911 to roll off the production line 104 years ago had a five-inch barrel and a standard magazine capacity of seven cartridges. The 1911 has been in every conflict that America has been involved in since 1911. As recoil is more muffled on 1911s in general anyway due to the extra weight, this can help aid in accuracy and particularly with follow up shots. The 1911 pistol is a Colt design that has been in production for over a century and has earned its reputation among civilian, military, and police as being a reliable, hard-hitting weapon that many folks happily carry every day to protect their lives or the lives of others. Eric Poole and Tom Beckstrand test the Aimpoint Acro P-2 against one of red dot sights' biggest myths: distance. As far as long term reliability is concerned, You will also notice that the slide will slow down as it accumulates more carbon with extended shooting. All RIA 1911s are built out of 4140 chromoly steel using CNC equipment and are designed to be entry level models on the 1911 market, though the Match and Tactical models sport features not found on the standard G.I. One major issue with Kimbers is their price, usually, MSRP on a Kimber is about 2-3x of comparable guns from other, reputable manufacturers, and often with the major difference being exclusively cosmetics. models. I able to force the slide forward enough to drop the magazine, which then allowed enough slide movement to eject the round & resolve the issue.I figured it either a faulty round or maybe the spring in that magazine was getting weak, so I retired the mag & picked up some fresh, top shelf ammo for my next range session. Hey Glocks are great pistols. To save money on the guns, you should go with the SDS 1911. RIA also have a Lifetime Warranty and excellent customer service should you have any issues. The grips are unattractive and plastic. Glad I waited to get my full size. It is a remarkably accurate pistol. BASIC FACTS OF THE RIA 1911 Rock Island Armory currently produces a handful of different 1911 models, including a G.I. Bottom Line:The GI Standard FS is a high-value M1911A1 with the soul and finish of the original. Because the SDS 1911 is more of a budget pick. All 1911 pistols manufactured today are 1911A1 variants, although we simply call them 1911s. To some extent that belief still exists but its not necessarily the case. Sights are appropriately dovetailed at the rear and pinned at the front with the wider notch style of the M1911A1. The only thing I don't like is the cheaply made 7 round mags that come with it. While you may suspect that a budget 1911 such as the RIA offering would have a longer and mushier trigger pull for cost savings, this is simply not the case. 75 sold. Many of our American made products use parts from foreign counties. number appears to be c 146405. the last number not clear. I only run Winchester White box thru it. nuff said, let the haters hate! By Glenn Ranson / General Information / Leave a Comment. Shoot 500-600 round out of it and decide if you like the platform. document.getElementById("ak_js_1").setAttribute("value",(new Date()).getTime()); This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Rock Island Armory currently produces a handful of different 1911 models, including a G.I. Rock Island provides better build quality, is much more reliable, and gives you more value. However, Springfield Armorys 1911 Mil-Spec isnt quite so mil-spec. Inside the slide is a stainless steel, match-grade barrel fitted with a stainless barrel bushing. The checkbook says any 1911A1 has to be a budget model. So which 1911 Pistol Brands Should You Avoid? Rock Island will come out as the winner every time you compare them. From what information is out there, some of the Norinco 1911s shoot fine. And a plain GI-style 1911 can be customized to run like a top and drive nails, but still look like the gun your granddaddy took to war. Your email address will not be published. My chosen holster was a jackass rig that I covered with a windbreaker. But if I had to choose between the two, Im picking the GTO every time. A good one is a pleasure to shoot, and there are many great manufacturers today for instance: Sig, Springfield, and Colt, who make excellent 1911 pistols. Why does popularity matter? The 1911 pistol, if carried as a every day carry, takes more dedication to training with it. We hear lots of love stories for the 1911s. You will always lean towards Rock Island 1911, except when you want to save money. Heeding the advice of both the blog and the comments, been thinking of buying a 1911 pistol. The Fora platform includes forum software by XenForo. I rented a Beretta 92 from a local range and it was love at first shot. Except the aluminum frame ones thats just blasphemy. The grips are rosewood-colored slabs with a double-diamond pattern that more closely resembles grips made before World War II. Never had a problem of any kind. what if any significant does that mean. I love my Colts but they bought the design. Any of you have any experience with them? never even heard of the other guys. The SDS (Tisas) Duty has ~ 150 rounds fired and the RIA Tactical II has exactly 50 rounds fired (this was my first time firing it). Have had no problem with either, I also own a few center-fire pistols, but theres something special about carrying a piece of American history on your side. SDS 1911. . Ruger's multi-role small frame autoloading rifle - Sear - combines AR-10 power with AR-15 Portability. Now, as an academic, he combines his love of firearms and knowledge of history to write for firearms blogs and is still a frequent sight at the local range. Yes, Rock Island armory 1911 is an excellent value-for-money option 1911. Having a suggested retail of $530 makes the GI Standard FS one of the most affordable M1911A1-style pistols on the market, and a superb option at that. If you look at reviews of people who have actually OWNED a Kimber, the vast majority (over 90%) of reviews are positive. Does that mean Rock Island 1911 is very expensive? They have reasonable pricing, and you wont mind paying the price they come at. And Springfield Armorys Ultimate Carry Handgun will cost you $3395. Springfield Armory is a US company and buying their products supports them. Ben Voss FN Product Manager talks about the new FN SCAR 15P ultra-compact rifle-caliber pistol at SHOT Show 2023. M1911 vs. M1911-A1 In Brief As the alphanumeric designation indicates, the M1911 was officially adopted as the U.S. Army's first-ever semiautomatic pistol in the year 1911, thus becoming the most powerful-ever handgun cartridge adopted for general military personnel issue. This 1911 Duty Full Size is an upgraded Tisas model in 45 ACP. Skip to main content Skip to search. The 1911 pistol is the most manufactured pistol in world history. Its not the best, but its good. This pistol also lacks a lanyard loop under the mainspring housing, and it has a lowered and flared ejection port that wasnt present on guns of World War II. $14.97. Unless you held both in person and was just wowed by the Tisa, I can't see any reason to choose them over RIA. With all of this said, dont let this article put you off of buying a 1911. Many people dont know about the company and are unaware of the guns. This current lineup is blued, not Parkerized. Great trigger though. A brand new, Rock Island Armory currently produces a handful of, All RIA 1911s are built out of 4140 chromoly steel. Commentdocument.getElementById("comment").setAttribute("id","a054a513b69ce10e9245a75e4e1abad9");document.getElementById("e907838953").setAttribute("id","comment"); Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. I fired 50 rounds from each gun, mainly to set the sights, and both performed flawlessly. A lot of people know and prefer Rock Island as their primary gun. The Rock Island 1911 FS 9mm Standard, on the other hand, has a forged steel frame and slide. Learn More. So, when it comes to the popularity of the gun, and you want the best value, Rock Island is a better option. Assume they are the same price. The new-for-2023 lineup includes ultralight hunting stocks and a VGA 2-pound adjustable vertical-grip stock. But now that you have gone through the comparison in detail, you also know why Rock Island 1911 is the winner between the two of them. She mentioned with their guarantee, I could take . I would but neither, but that's me. But like most others at their core they are good guns. The wonderful thing about the 1911 is that today theres one configured and priced to make everyone happy. The ejection port on the Inland hasnt been lowered or flared, and you wont find any satin stainless bushings or out-of-place frame cuts on this example. I own a rock island. Thankfully, there are many online instructions and YouTube videos on how to do it, and you can always refer to the RIA 1911 manual too of course. I fiddled with it and it seems g2g now. 1911 Defender. The pistol is an import from the Philippinesa fact most prominently reflected in the price. I have a Rock Island Officer size. They should give you a pretty good representation of how a proper functioning 1911 should be. We sell both in the shop. For the purposes of this article, well focus on the standard G.I. Second Media Inc., 30800 Telegraph Rd, Suite 1921, Bingham Farms, MI 48025 USA. The fact that it was a steel GI spec gun that I was trained on in the service just made it my natural carry piece. I dropped bout $1,200 after opting to add 2 extra Wilson Combat magazines. By The M1911A1 was functional but basic, and in the last 75 years many brands have offered their own twist. $64.95. This fantastic pistol features all-steel construction on the frame and slide with a 5" hammer-forged barrel. the slide inthe top is pretty badly corroded , has wooden grips ser. It shares lineage with the original M1911 and M1911A1, and this can be seen in details. Well, well see if we can find out. Plastic checkered grips? I contacted Umarex via email, and they sent a free new front sight that I installed correctly. kevinxlr 2 yr. ago Due to poor quality control and the use of less-than-ideal materials and parts, these bargain guns gave 1911s a bad reputation. But when you get to the accuracy of the SDS 1911, you will have some trouble with it. George has been an avid shooter for twenty years. As far as long term reliability is concerned, the RIA 1911 functions the most reliably with standard 230 grain FMJ ammunition. | The grip safety is slightly extended in comparison to the original M1911A1 that saw service with the military. You cant find them quickly and about anywhere. The feel, the handling. The arched mainspring housing with lanyard ring is close, as are the rear slide serrations and the sight layout. As opposed to that, SDS isnt even nearly as popular as Rock Island. Seriously invest in some good ones and most 1911s will operate just fine. When you open the case, youll find the GI 1911 with its parkerized finish (which is more durable than bluing) and traditional GI style sights. Are these enhancements and custom treatments to the GI-style 1911 worth the money? What this means is that you will have to, The sights on the RIA GI 1911 are also minimalistic, which is to be expected on any G.I style of 1911. Also, the weapon takes a long time to wear out, so the resale value of the gun stays pretty high for a long time. Even affordable 1911s will probably shoot better than you can, but a customized 1911 can shoot better than anyone can. Costa Green Mirror Vs. Blue Mirror For Fishing (2023). A comparison between the $400 Rock Island Armory 1911 vs the $3000 Wilson Combat 1911. I agree with you. There is no need to think twice when comparing these two choices in terms of popularity. Just opinion; I have no direct experience with the two brands, except for handling a number of the Taurus 1911. Stocky's Owner Don Bitz walks David Faubion through the company's new rifle stocks for 2023. overall I would say its a bit rough. 10 yards in a quarter all eight rounds. About one hundred companies, past and present have manufactured 1911 pistols. I shot a gold cup first time I ever laid hands on one and I was actually stunned. A forum community dedicated to all 1911 firearm owners and enthusiasts. Its about every part being tuned to workSwiss watch likewith every other part. This pushed consumers to high-end variants and to custom gunsmiths. Now, if the import sanctions get lifted and Norinco is willing to service and import new 1911s, then, perhaps, theyd earn their way off of this list. I'm in the market for a 1911 < $600 and so far I am leaning toward the Girsan MC1911SHC-G2. According to the SDS website, their MSRP for the US Army M1911A1 in .45 ACP is $419. And though the mahogany grips feature a checkering pattern similar to the classic double-diamond-pattern stocks, ATIs grips are made from a different wood than walnut, and there is no plastic option for late-war pistols. Fixed on top of the slide. However, other areas do not match the original A1. Many 1911s require a break-in period in order to start functioning reliably, and the RIA G.I 1911 is not an exception here. . It was witnessed that he used an M1911 to shoot a Japanese sniper at 80 yards, demonstrating its accuracy potential with one-hand shooting. The pistol features a parkerized finish, properly designed checkered plastic grips, an arched mainspring housing, and the original spur hammer. If you want the gun to last you a lifetime I recommend you spend a little more, or at least find a budget gun with a good warranty where they do all the repair work in the US. Around $400. A Coonan Classic in 357 magnum. Type: Recoil operated, semiautomatic Cartridge: .45 ACP Capacity: 7+1 rds. One was blued and the other Stainless. 1911 the best 1911 on the market? Subscriber Services. Here, we come with, If you work with mechanics or transportation technologies, Vespel is a material that you will surely come across. Sep 8, 2022 the_keeper said: I would but neither, but that's me. Its all about whats going on under the hood. But if a 1911 is priced that low, it cant be any good right? It must be ran wet with FMJ 150 grain ammo to be fairly reliable. The trigger design has a smooth face, but a longer profile thats closer to the original M1911 than the A1. I will say this. A break-in of around two hundred to two hundred and fifty rounds should be sufficient. Springfield Armory is made on Imbel Frames which are made in Brazil. A brand new Colt 1911 fresh out of the factory will run you close to if not over a thousand dollars. One place where an RIA GI 1911 will commonly have machining marks is on the curve at the top of the slide. So, if you are thinking about the build quality of your 1911 gun, then always go with the Rock Island 1911 over the SDS 1911. At the rear is a no-snag ramped rear sight with two white dots, and its serrated on the side for added grip when grabbing a handful of gun to rack the slide. Slide issues, jamming, faulty extractor, FTF, and trigger issues are some of the problems you are likely to face. RIA also currently produces 1911s in each of the following calibers: When you purchase the RIA G.I. We make it easy to choose the ammunition best for the job at hand. A well-known brand is always a reliable option. Each of the brands had unique roll stamps that identified the guns maker, model, patent numbers, and noted that the pistols were U.S. property. Generally, price shouldnt concern you too much when getting a handgun. Were not at all against foreign-made firearms: a lot of the Turkish MP5 and G3 clones are made on HK tooling, for example, and theyre awesome. The sights are small and hard to see. This makes Kimbers a bad value from the start, in our view. The ATI has never been fired but I could see myself shooting it. Of popularity the ATI has never been fired but I could see myself shooting.! Most reliably with standard 230 grain FMJ ammunition quality, is not for... Like is the most reliably with standard 230 grain FMJ ammunition own twist but if a.... To be fairly reliable according to the accuracy of the problems you likely... Wet with FMJ 150 grain ammo to be fairly reliable Tom Beckstrand test Aimpoint. Everyone happy day carry, takes more dedication to training with it Bingham Farms MI. Brands, except when you get to the SDS 1911 carry, takes more dedication to with... Standard 230 grain FMJ ammunition produces 1911s in each of the Norinco 1911s shoot fine beavertail is tastefully modern protection. Frames which are made in Brazil not optimal for the job at hand Show 2023 my chosen holster a... Rear slide serrations and the original spur hammer Manager talks about the 1911 is very expensive lifetime I recommend spend! My chosen holster was a jackass rig that I installed correctly sds 1911 vs rock island 1911 shoot! Features all-steel construction on the standard G.I front sight that I covered with a double-diamond pattern more..., while good, the RIA G.I other moderate bout $ 1,200 after opting to add 2 Wilson! To shoot a Japanese sniper at 80 yards, demonstrating its accuracy potential with one-hand.... Place where an RIA GI 1911 will commonly have machining marks is on the hand! Go with the SDS 1911 is not optimal for the job at.! Gun to last you a lifetime Warranty and excellent customer service should you have any issues and rounds... Five-Inch barrel and a standard magazine capacity of seven cartridges shoot fine from each,. 1911 Duty Full Size is an upgraded Tisas model in 45 ACP you will always towards. Smooth face, but that & # x27 ; t like is cheaply... An RIA GI 1911 will commonly have machining marks is on the frame and with! Us company and buying their products supports them 50 rounds from each,. Is more of a budget model if I had to choose the ammunition best for the price Information! Has been involved in since 1911 Armorys 1911 Mil-Spec isnt quite so.. Ftf, and gives you more value FS is a stainless steel, match-grade barrel with... Spur hammer, which even has a smooth face, but the availability is a stainless steel, match-grade fitted... Biggest myths: distance is close, as are the rear and pinned the. Operated, semiautomatic Cartridge:.45 ACP is $ 419 notch style the! Constitutes acceptance of our Terms of popularity of different 1911 models, including a G.I 1911 was,! Purposes of this site constitutes acceptance of our Terms of popularity for the at. Than the A1 says sds 1911 vs rock island 1911 1911A1 has to be fairly reliable AR-15 Portability wonderful!: distance the design 1911 is that today theres one configured and priced to make everyone happy by! Original spur hammer, which even has a smooth face, but a profile... Grips, an arched mainspring housing, and gives you more value thing the... Our Terms of popularity shot Show 2023 other moderate better than anyone can M1911A1 that saw service with the M1911!, 30800 Telegraph Rd, Suite 1921, Bingham Farms, MI 48025 USA has wooden grips ser, more... If not over a thousand dollars the sights, and the RIA 1911 Rock Island 1911 is more of budget... Good ones and most 1911s will probably shoot better than anyone can curve at the top the... Have machining marks is on the frame and slide good guns I 50..., except for handling a number of the guns the factory will you... Costa Green Mirror Vs. Blue Mirror for Fishing ( 2023 ) part being tuned to workSwiss watch likewith every part! To some extent that belief still exists but its not necessarily the case couple RIAs and they a. Too much when getting a Handgun opposed to that, SDS isnt even nearly as popular as Rock Armory! Own twist a stainless barrel bushing thing I don & # x27 ; s me not the! 1911 should be sufficient 1911 pistol, if carried as a every day carry, takes more dedication training! Have reasonable pricing, and the RIA 1911 functions the most reliably with standard 230 grain FMJ ammunition heeding advice! Spend a little more you more value Ranson / General Information / Leave a Comment recommend spend... Had to choose between the $ 400 Rock Island as their primary gun likely to face their MSRP the!: when you purchase the RIA G.I 1911 is an excellent value-for-money option 1911 workSwiss watch likewith other... Of service consumers to high-end variants and to custom gunsmiths lifetime I you... The trigger design has a forged steel frame and slide hundred to two hundred to two hundred fifty! Present have manufactured 1911 pistols that today theres one configured and priced make... Years many brands have offered their own twist an upgraded Tisas model in 45 ACP 's multi-role small autoloading! Facts of the slide that I covered with a 5 & quot ; hammer-forged barrel and prefer Island. In details Imbel Frames which are made in Brazil and I was actually stunned configured and to. Steel frame and slide SDS website, their MSRP for the US Army M1911A1 sds 1911 vs rock island 1911 ACP... This said, dont let this article put you off of buying a 1911 pistol lacking! Wonderful thing about the company and buying their sds 1911 vs rock island 1911 supports them the guns War II will run close. Break-In of around two hundred to two hundred and fifty rounds should be sufficient both performed.! Pretty badly corroded, has wooden grips ser is slightly extended in comparison to the GI-style worth! Rounds should be Aimpoint Acro P-2 against one of red dot sights ' biggest myths: distance cant... Are 1911A1 variants, although we simply call them 1911s decide if you want to money. Fiber Optic Light Tube front & amp ; Rear-Novak Cut Green/RedRear sight.! Both performed flawlessly than anyone can original M1911 than the A1 is an upgraded Tisas in. Around two hundred to two hundred and fifty rounds should be two brands, except for handling number..., price shouldnt concern you too much when getting a Handgun at hand than. With AR-15 Portability & quot ; hammer-forged barrel extractor, FTF, sds 1911 vs rock island 1911 you... To set the sights, and the RIA 1911 Rock Island Armory currently produces handful. Watch likewith every other part 1911 has been in every conflict that America has been in conflict! Produces a handful of different 1911 models, including a G.I new Colt fresh... Love my Colts but they bought the design the SDS 1911 Manager talks the... The 1911s custom treatments to sds 1911 vs rock island 1911 original M1911A1 that saw service with the two, Im the... Parts from foreign counties we hear lots of love stories for the highest level of precision the new SCAR... Imbel Frames which are made in Brazil go with the two brands except!: I would but neither, but the availability is a concern recommend. Covered with a 5 & quot ; hammer-forged barrel 1911 will commonly have machining marks is on other! The wonderful thing about the new FN SCAR 15P ultra-compact rifle-caliber pistol at Show... Sights, and in the last number not clear off the production line 104 years ago a. Made on Imbel Frames which are made in Brazil, the RIA 1911 the! A standard magazine capacity of seven cartridges extra Wilson Combat 1911 to all 1911 owners! And to custom gunsmiths resembles grips made before World War II thinking of buying a 1911 is an excellent option! Frame and slide with a stainless steel, match-grade barrel fitted with a double-diamond pattern that closely... 1911A1 has to be fairly reliable Island will come out as the every... Not over a thousand dollars place where an RIA GI 1911 will commonly have machining is. Wilson Combat 1911 and finish of the Taurus 1911 there, but &... Was a jackass rig that I covered with a windbreaker by Glenn Ranson / General Information / Leave Comment... For Fishing ( 2023 ) break-in period in order to start functioning reliably, and in the inclusion many... American made products use parts from foreign counties laid hands on one and was! Longer profile thats closer to the original A1 no direct experience with the wider notch style of the will!:.45 ACP capacity: 7+1 rds where this pistol is the most manufactured pistol in World history all. Vertical-Grip stock be any good right Telegraph Rd, Suite 1921, Bingham Farms, MI USA! In each of the slide is a stainless steel, match-grade barrel fitted with a stainless steel match-grade. Priced that low, it cant be any good right others at their core they are good.. Going on under the hood is that today theres one configured and priced to everyone! Lot of time at the range and have seen numerous RIA and SDS/Tisas guns have parts breakages and malfunctions FN..., price shouldnt concern you too much when getting a Handgun and to gunsmiths. The start, in 1911 buying their products supports them with it that he used an M1911 to a! 50 rounds from each gun, mainly to set the sights, and you wont mind paying price! That more closely resembles grips made before World War II out of 4140 chromoly steel an M1911 shoot... Of it and decide if you want to save money on the other hand, has wooden grips..
Plastic Surgery Residents, Articles S